Nothing says summer like a big scoop of your favorite ice cream. Whether you’re exploring the Catskills on a warm afternoon or capping off a lakeside day with a sweet treat, Sullivan County has no shortage of spots serving up classic cones, small-batch scoops, and over-the-top sundaes.

Here are some of our favorite ice cream shops across the county, the perfect way to cool down on a hot summer day.

🍨 1. Carousel Ice Cream Stand – Jeffersonville

A true local favorite, this charming roadside ice cream stand in the heart of Jeffersonville is a must-stop in the summer. With its cheerful carousel-themed décor and shaded picnic area, it’s a hit with families and day-trippers alike.

Try: A classic twist cone or a towering soft-serve sundae with all the toppings.

**Carousel Ice Cream Stand -** Image From Google

🍦 2. Custer’s Last Stand – Wurtsboro

This beloved roadside ice cream stand along Route 209 is hard to miss — and even harder to resist. Known for its quirky name and generous portions, Custer’s Last Stand serves up soft-serve, sundaes, shakes, and more with that classic summer vibe.

Try: A banana split or one of their epic flurries packed with toppings.

**Custers Last Stand** - Image From Google

🍓 3. Main Street Farm Creamery (inside Main Street Farm) – Livingston Manor

Known for their local eats and curated goods, Main Street Farm also scoops up small-batch ice cream with a focus on local ingredients. It’s perfect for grabbing a cone and strolling along Main Street.

Try: Hudson Valley-made ice cream in unique seasonal flavors.

**Main Street Farm** - Image From Google

🍧 4. Sprinkles Ice Cream & Grill – Narrowsburg

This sweet stop in Narrowsburg offers classic grill fare and a wide variety of ice cream options, from soft serve and milkshakes to sundaes and hand-scooped favorites. Enjoy your treat outside with a view of charming Narrowsburg.

Try: A thick milkshake or soft serve with sprinkles, of course!

🧁 5. Sticky Fingers Delectables – Kauneonga Lake

Just steps from the lake, this adorable dessert shop offers gourmet ice cream, baked goods, and frozen treats in a whimsical setting. It’s the perfect stop after dinner or a day on the water.

Try: Ice cream sandwiched between house-made cookies or one of their fun specialty sundaes.

🍒 6. Bethel Creamery – Swan Lake

If you’re in the area for a Bethel Woods concert or exploring White Lake, don’t miss this kosher creamery offering locally made ice cream, milk, and other dairy products.

Try: Chocolate milkshakes or fresh scoops of their signature ice cream flavors.

🍦 7. Quickway Twin Cone – Bloomingburg

This longtime favorite off Route 17 offers both hard and soft-serve, plus sundaes and flurries in generous sizes. It’s a classic stop for road-trippers and locals alike.

Try: A peanut butter cup flurry or a classic vanilla twist dipped in chocolate.

**Quickway Twin Cone** - Image From Google

🍨 8. Ollie Greys – Callicoon

Located right on Main Street, Ollie Greys aka Callicoon Creamery serves up delicious hard scoop ice cream with rotating seasonal flavors and a welcoming vibe. Perfect after exploring the farmers market or walking by the river.

Try: A double scoop of black raspberry and mint chip in a waffle cone.

Whether you're into classic soft serve or artisanal scoops, these Sullivan County ice cream spots offer the perfect way to cool off and treat yourself during your summer adventures. Pair it with a scenic drive, a hike, or a dip in the lake — and you’ve got yourself a Catskills summer day done right.

Planning your trip?
We offer unique vacation rentals across Sullivan County including stays near all your favorite ice cream stops. Stay cool and stay with us!

Follow us on Instagram for more Sullivan County Trips and Gems! - @Casskellstays

🍦 Chill Out: The Best Ice Cream Spots in Sullivan County to Beat the Heat