Looking to escape the usual tourist stops and discover something special? Sullivan County is filled with unique places that don’t always make it onto the typical travel guides. From serene trails to magical little shops and creative experiences, these hidden gems are perfect for curious travelers and weekend wanderers.

Here are 7 under-the-radar spots that locals love and visitors should know about:

🛶 1. Mongaup River Trail – Forestburgh

Tucked away in Forestburgh, this quiet riverside trail winds along the Mongaup River, offering peaceful water views, shaded woods, and a soundtrack of birdsong. It’s ideal for a relaxing walk, light fishing, or simply soaking in nature without the crowds.

🍞 2. Dutch’s Tavern & General Store – Rock Hill

Part vintage shop, part eatery, Dutch’s feels like stepping back in time. It’s got old-school charm, retro signs, local goods, and hearty food. Grab a homemade sandwich or pie, browse the shelves, and enjoy a slow-paced stop that feels delightfully out of step with modern life.

🎨 3. Staircase Gallery at the Catskill Art Society – Livingston Manor

You’ve heard of the Catskill Art Society, but have you wandered the upstairs hallway? This hidden gallery space showcases rotating experimental art shows and community exhibits that are easy to miss — and totally worth discovering.

💎 4. Crystal Connection – Wurtsboro

Set inside a former church, this crystal and mineral shop feels truly magical. With stained glass windows and soaring ceilings, Crystal Connection is not just a store — it’s a spiritual experience. Perfect for collectors, mystics, or anyone needing a good vibe reset.

🏞 5. Witch’s Hole State Forest – Parksville

A little off the beaten path and full of local lore, Witch’s Hole is perfect for seasoned hikers looking for something new. You’ll find solitude, mossy forest paths, and a quiet atmosphere that makes the whole place feel enchanted.

☕️ 6. The Walk In Manor – Livingston Manor

A charming walk-up coffee bar tucked right off Main Street, this new local favorite serves up espresso, matcha, and seasonal specialties with a warm, small-town feel. Whether you’re grabbing a to-go cup or stopping to chat with the friendly staff, it’s the perfect fuel for your Catskills day.

🚗 7. Stone Arch Bridge Historic Park – Kenoza Lake

Quaint, quiet, and incredibly photogenic, this hidden park is perfect for picnics, peaceful walks, and soaking in Sullivan County’s rustic beauty. Don’t forget to snap a photo of the arched stone bridge over the babbling brook.

🏡 Make It a Weekend

If you're exploring hidden gems, you’ll want a cozy and convenient home base. The Forest Chalet in Parksville offers secluded comfort and is just a short drive from most of these treasures. Book your stay and make your Sullivan County trip truly unforgettable.

Hidden Gems in Sullivan County, NY