🎁 Holiday Shopping Guide: Sullivan County, NY

The holidays in the Sullivan Catskills feel like something out of a snow-globe—quiet streets lined with twinkling lights, cozy cafés, and locally owned shops filled with one-of-a-kind finds. Whether you're staying with us at Casskell Stays or visiting for a festive weekend getaway, the local towns of Narrowsburg, Callicoon, Jeffersonville, and Livingston Manor offer some of the most charming holiday shopping in the region.

From artisan-made home goods to curated vintage, handcrafted jewelry, and thoughtful gifts for every personality, this guide highlights the very best spots to support small businesses while discovering something truly special.

Let’s go town by town and find the perfect gifts for everyone on your list.

🎄 NARROWSBURG

Iris

A bright and inspiring arts-and-crafts supply shop perfect for creative souls.
Gift ideas:

• Watercolor, acrylic, or gouache sets

• Journaling tools & specialty papers

• Craft kits for kids and adults

• Embellishments, markers, stamps, pens

• DIY project bundles you can assemble yourself

Madame Fortuna

A stunning vintage-luxe boutique featuring fine jewelry, antiques, and sculptural design.
Gift ideas:

• Vintage rings & necklaces

• Mid-century home décor pieces

• Antique trinket boxes

• Curated statement earrings

• Elegant one-of-a-kind treasures

Catskills Curated

A shop filled with artisan-made goods from local makers.
Gift ideas:

• Hand-poured candles

• Locally made cutting boards

• Gourmet snacks & pantry items

• Small-batch skincare

• Handmade ornaments

One Grand Books

A literary gem with beautifully curated titles.
Gift ideas:

• Books from the “10 favorite books” collections

• Journals & notebooks

• Coffee-table books

• Stationery sets

• Literary gift bundles

🎄 CALLICOON

The Callicoon Marketplace

Home to several makers and mini-boutiques, all under one roof.
Gift ideas:

• Artisanal foods

• Small-batch home goods

• Vintage accessories

• Handmade soaps & self-care gifts

• Gifts from rotating holiday pop-up vendors

Spruce Home Goods

A cozy home store offering a mix of pantry items, kitchen goods, and décor.
Gift ideas:

• Gourmet cheese & local treats

• Cocktails kits or mixers

• Wooden spoons & kitchenware

• Holiday candles

• Cozy textiles

Litt Home & Book (inside the Marketplace)

Curated books, vintage décor, and thoughtful goods.
Gift ideas:

• Rare book finds

• Vintage décor

• Unique serving pieces

• Handpicked home styling gifts

Wool Worth

A dream shop for knitters, crocheters, and fiber artists.
Gift ideas:

• Hand-dyed yarn

• Knitting kits

• Vintage sewing notions

• Pattern books

• Fiber-arts gift bundles

Ragtime Clothing Exchange

Curated vintage and stylish secondhand clothing.
Gift ideas:

• Vintage coats

• Jewelry

• Curated holiday outfits

• Retro accessories

Callicoon Vintage

A must-visit shop for nostalgic finds.
Gift ideas:

• Vintage décor

• Vinyl records

• Antique art

• Retro holiday decorations

Lee Hartwell Antiques

Perfect for those who love old-world charm.
Gift ideas:

• Estate jewelry

• Antique silver

• Vintage perfume bottles

• Classic décor pieces

🎄 JEFFERSONVILLE

R52 Home (inside Sullivan Sundries)

A variety shop blending vintage and modern décor.
Gift ideas:

• Tabletop décor

• Vintage glassware

• Unique lamps

• Housewarming sets

• Stylish home accents

Sullivan Mercantile

Textile-forward décor and handcrafted home goods.
Gift ideas:

• Handmade pillows

• Artisan blankets

• Linen sets

• Locally made décor

• Festive tableware

The Vintage House

A charming shop offering antique and vintage finds.
Gift ideas:

• Retro cookware

• Vintage ornaments

• Collectible décor

• One-of-a-kind statement pieces

🎄 LIVINGSTON MANOR

Old Souls

Outdoorsy, cabin-style boutique perfect for adventurers.
Gift ideas:

• Flannels & outdoor apparel

• Camp mugs

• Field guides

• Knives, tools & gear

• Catskills-branded merch

Long Weekend

Photo-worthy home goods and lifestyle items.
Gift ideas:

• Ceramics & mugs

• Minimalist décor

• Candles & incense

• Coffee-table books

• Stocking stuffer accessories

Corners Design Shop

A design lover’s dream.
Gift ideas:

• Art prints

• Stationery

• Modern décor

• Thoughtfully curated home pieces

DROOZ & Company

A general store with a modern twist.
Gift ideas:

• Holiday ornaments

• Stylish home goods

• Handcrafted décor

• Art prints & local designs

Life Repurposed

Sustainable, curated secondhand shopping.
Gift ideas:

• Vintage apparel

• Repurposed décor

• Upcycled home accessories

Homestedt Catskills

Rustic, Scandinavian-inspired shop.
Gift ideas:

• Wool blankets

• Cozy knitwear

• Minimal home goods

• Local pantry treats

✨ Conclusion

Holiday shopping in the Sullivan Catskills is more than checking off your gift list—it’s an experience filled with charm, creativity, and community. Each of these small businesses offers something special, whether it’s a handcrafted keepsake, a vintage treasure, or a thoughtful piece for the home. When you shop local, you’re not only finding meaningful gifts—you’re also supporting the makers, artists, and shopkeepers who make this region feel so warm and welcoming.

Whether you're visiting for a cozy winter stay or planning a festive shopping weekend, the Catskills are the perfect place to discover gifts with heart, story, and soul.